What Is the 5-Year Tax Compliance Requirement for Renouncing US Citizenship?
Form 8854 and the Section 877(a)(2)(C) Certification: Must Your Tax Compliance Come Before You Renounce?
On this page:
Read the full analysis here.
What is the certification requirement under Section 877(a)(2)(C)?
A former U.S. citizen or long-term green card holder (a lawful permanent resident, or LPR) becomes a “covered expatriate” under Section 877(a)(2)(C) if they fail to certify, under penalty of perjury, that they have met their federal tax requirements for the 5 preceding taxable years. The statute treats a person as covered if “(C) such individual fails to certify under penalty of perjury that he has met the requirements of this title for the 5 preceding taxable years or fails to submit such evidence of such compliance as the Secretary may require.” A “covered expatriate” is a person who triggers the U.S. exit tax rules on giving up citizenship or LPR status.
What makes someone a “covered expatriate”?
If you expatriated after June 16, 2008, the expatriation rules apply if any one of these statements is true:
- Your average annual net income tax liability for the 5 tax years ending before the date of your expatriation is more than the listed amount.
- Your net worth is $2 million or more on the date of your expatriation.
- You fail to certify on Form 8854 that you have complied with all of your federal tax obligations for the 5 tax years preceding the date of your expatriation.
The third test is the certification requirement, and it is the one tied to the timing question below.
Does an IRS form or its instructions carry the “force of law”?
An IRS form and its conditions may not carry the “force of law.” Treasury and the IRS cannot create law by publishing a substantive rule in a form. The statute is what binds. This matters because a form instruction can state a condition that the statute itself does not, and anyone citing a form will want to keep that distinction in mind.
Do the Form 8854 instructions require tax compliance before the expatriation date?
The instructions read that way. The Form 8854 instructions state that the certification must reflect that you have “complied with all of your federal tax obligations for the 5 tax years preceding the date of your expatriation.” Taken literally, that language points to compliance completed before the expatriation or renunciation date. The statute, Section 877(a)(2)(C), does not specify whether the certification has to be made before or after the date of loss of nationality.
Can you come into compliance after renouncing and still avoid covered expatriate status?
This is the open question the form instructions raise. If the instructions are correct, a person could not satisfy the rule by attempting to comply with all federal tax obligations after renouncing. Under that reading, coming into compliance for 5 years and then filing Form 8854, all after taking the oath of renunciation, would not let the person avoid “covered expatriate” status. The statute itself does not say the certification must come before the date of loss of nationality, so whether the instructions can impose that timing is unsettled.
Are there Treasury regulations that settle this question?
No. Treasury has issued no regulations on this point to date. There are only a few notices. One of them is IRS Notice 2009-85 on expatriation, and its own “force of law” is itself open to question. Without regulations, a form instruction is not the same as binding law.
Could the IRS still challenge someone who complies after renouncing?
Yes. Even where a form instruction may not carry the force of law, the IRS may still challenge a former U.S. citizen or LPR who does not also meet the condition set out in the IRS’s own instructions. The agency could argue that the person failed the certification requirement of Section 877(a)(2)(C) by not satisfying tax compliance before the expatriation date.
Why does this matter before taking the oath of renunciation?
The timing of tax compliance is a detail a former U.S. citizen or green card holder may want to weigh carefully before renouncing. The statute is silent on whether the certification must come before the date of loss of nationality, while the form instructions point to compliance before that date, so the literal-statute reading and the form-instruction reading can diverge. Consult an experienced attorney before rushing off to take the oath of renunciation.
Read the full analysis here.
What Is the Difference Between Willful and Non-Willful FBAR Violations?
Table of contents
Read the full analysis here.
What do “willful” and “non-willful” mean for US citizens and green-card holders living abroad who have not filed?
“Willful” and “non-willful” describe how a failure to file is characterized. For any US citizen (USC) or lawful permanent resident (LPR, a green-card holder) living outside the US who has not been filing US income tax returns or FBARs (the Foreign Bank Account Report), the willfulness question is one of the most important to understand. The IRS “streamlined” procedure requires a taxpayer to certify that the conduct was non-willful. The distinction shapes the options a person has for correcting past filings.
Why does the willful or non-willful question matter for a US citizen or green-card holder overseas?
The willful or non-willful question matters because it shapes what steps a US citizen or green-card holder living abroad needs to take about filing US income tax returns. The answer affects how a person who has not been filing may approach cleaning up past returns and FBAR filings.
Can a green-card holder living in a tax-treaty country clean up past US tax filings?
A green-card holder who lives predominantly in a country that has a US income tax treaty may be in the best position to clean up past US tax filings and return positions. The US has 68 income tax treaties. Under the “tie-breaker provisions” of such a treaty, typically Article 4, the person’s facts may allow them to file as a non-resident, and those filings may apply to several prior years.
When is a green-card holder no longer treated as a lawful permanent resident for US tax purposes?
A green-card holder is no longer treated as a lawful permanent resident for US federal tax purposes under IRC Section 7701(b)(6) when three tests are met:
- the individual is treated as a resident of a foreign country under the provisions of a tax treaty;
- the individual does not waive the benefits of the treaty; and
- the individual notifies the Secretary of the commencement of such treatment.
When a green-card holder notifies the IRS that he or she is not a US resident under an applicable income tax treaty and files the treaty position accordingly, the issue of “expatriation” becomes front and center.
Can a green card be given up for tax purposes just by moving outside the US?
In some cases, yes. Since the 2008 tax law changes, lawful permanent resident status can be abandoned for tax purposes by merely leaving and moving outside the US.
Does giving up long-term green-card status trigger the US exit tax?
Giving up green-card status can trigger the US “exit tax” for a green-card holder treated as a “long-term resident.” A green-card holder who has held that status for 8 years or more is generally treated as a long-term resident and may be subject to the exit tax of IRC Sections 877 and 877A. A separate tax may also apply to future US persons who receive gifts or inheritances from such a former green-card holder under Section 2801.
What does the IRS streamlined procedure require taxpayers to certify?
The IRS “streamlined” procedure, announced on June 18, 2014, has specific requirements that obligate the taxpayer to certify “non-willful” behavior. That certification is made under penalty of perjury. Where a green-card holder’s past failure to file US income tax returns was not non-willful, difficult legal questions arise about the consequences.
Read the full analysis here.
What Is a FATCA Intergovernmental Agreement and Is It Really Two-Way?
FATCA IGAs and the One-Way Reporting Gap: What US Persons and Foreign Residents Actually Face
Table of contents
Read the full analysis here.
What is FATCA, and how many countries have FATCA agreements with the United States?
FATCA (the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act) is the US law behind the intergovernmental agreements (IGAs) that the US Treasury negotiated with some 113 countries. Treasury publishes the full country list on its website. Not all of these countries have actually signed. Many have what Treasury calls an “agreement in substance.” The IGAs require foreign financial institutions (FFIs, meaning non-US financial institutions) to identify “U.S. Persons” and “Substantial U.S. Owners,” and to report what the IGAs call “U.S. Reportable Accounts.” Treasury describes the agreements as “bilateral.” One published example, the FATCA IGA with Colombia, is largely identical in form to almost every other IGA.
How do FATCA IGAs affect US citizens and green-card holders living outside the United States?
They affect US citizens (USCs) and lawful permanent residents (LPRs, green-card holders) in many ways. Foreign financial institutions around the world now collect extensive information to identify account holders who are “U.S. Persons” or “Specified U.S. Persons,” the term the IGAs use for accounts that must be reported. If you received questions from a foreign bank asking whether you are a US person, FATCA is why. The reporting reaches beyond direct accounts. It also reaches entities that a US person controls.
Why are some foreign banks refusing or closing accounts for US citizens and LPRs?
Many FFIs have adopted a policy to no longer accept or retain US accounts. The cost of complying with FATCA for US citizens and lawful permanent residents is high. Many FFIs also want to avoid the risk of being penalized heavily by the US federal government, including being charged with aiding and abetting US taxpayers to evade their US tax obligations. Jack Townsend’s website, Federal Tax Crimes, reviews these cases in detail, with particular focus on Swiss banks and the US DOJ Program for Swiss Banks.
What is the difference between a “U.S. Reportable Account” and a “Country X Reportable Account”?
This difference is the core asymmetry of FATCA. A “U.S. Reportable Account” is defined extraordinarily broadly. A “Country X Reportable Account,” for example a Colombian Reportable Account, is defined narrowly. That gap is why the IGAs are not truly bilateral: US banks do not have to provide the same detailed information on their non-US clients that FFIs must provide on US accounts. A plain reading of the IGAs gets you to that conclusion.
What income must a US bank report on a foreign resident’s account?
Only a limited slice. A Colombian Reportable Account obligates US banks to send information on US source income of individual residents under chapter 3, plus certain accounts of Colombian entities. All non-US source income of a Colombia resident individual is not subject to reporting by the US financial institution. A Colombian resident could hold a US$150M portfolio of non-US mutual funds and ADRs (American Depositary Receipts) traded on the NYSE, with none of that income reported to the Colombian government. Stock sales of US corporations such as Apple, Ford, or Microsoft are not treated as “US source income” under chapter 3 either.
Can a foreign resident use an offshore company to avoid US bank reporting?
Yes, under the IGAs as written. If a Colombian resident holds investments through an offshore corporation, for example a BVI (British Virgin Islands) company, no reporting is required of the US financial institution. That holds even if the entire US$150M portfolio is invested in US stocks, US treasuries, and other American financial investments. Individuals resident in countries such as the UK, France, Mexico, China, the Netherlands, Spain, Colombia, Brazil, Belgium, Guatemala, and Luxembourg can generally hold US investment assets through opaque legal structures and hide behind the entity. A US financial institution has no duty to identify or disclose the beneficial owners to those residents’ tax authorities.
What must a foreign bank report on an account controlled by a US person?
Far more. A “U.S. Reportable Account” includes a US Person who is a “Controlling Person” of a “Non-U.S. Entity.” Take the reverse example: a Colombian bank must identify all of its clients holding non-US entities, an expensive due diligence process, and then determine whether each entity such as a BVI company has a “Specified U.S. Person” behind it. It does not matter whether the income comes from Colombian sources or non-Colombian sources. Income is income, and the FFI must report it. Banks in at least 113 countries must drill down and collect detailed information on the beneficial owners of basically all companies, trusts, and other legal entities, to find “U.S. persons” and “substantial U.S. owners” as defined in the FATCA regulations.
Can US taxpayers hide assets behind offshore entities under FATCA?
Generally no. FFIs must provide extensive information on all income in a “U.S. Reportable Account” to the IRS, either directly or indirectly through their own governments. US taxpayers cannot hide behind offshore opaque legal entities. It is generally illegal for US citizens to form and hold assets in a foreign corporation without reporting that corporation’s assets, activities, and earnings. Such a foreign corporation would generally be a CFC (controlled foreign corporation) or possibly a PFIC (passive foreign investment company).
Read the full analysis here.
Who Was FATCA Actually Aimed At? The Law’s Origins and Unintended Consequences
Read the full analysis here.
What is FATCA, and when did it take effect?
FATCA (the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act) is a US law that went into effect on 1 January 2014. Since then, there have been an increasing number of consequences for United States citizens (USCs) and lawful permanent residents (LPRs, or green-card holders) who live overseas.
What was FATCA designed to do?
FATCA was built to bring transparency to the worldwide assets of US citizens and green-card holders. Its intended consequences include:
- Identifying non-US financial, investment, and company assets held by USCs and LPRs.
- Identifying the foreign financial institution (FFI) where those assets are located.
- Identifying non-financial foreign entities (NFFE) owned by a USC or LPR.
- Generally bringing transparency to the assets, accounts, and information about the worldwide assets of USCs and LPRs.
Much of this information gets collected through IRS forms, including Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, and W-9 used by USCs and LPRs overseas. To carry this out around the world, the US Treasury Department negotiated FATCA Intergovernmental Agreements (IGAs) with various countries.
Who was FATCA originally meant to target?
The group FATCA originally targeted was US resident individuals who were evading taxes through foreign financial institutions. The focus was on US resident taxpayers, even though the US imposes income tax on the worldwide income of US citizens living anywhere in the world. This understanding comes from extensive conversations with ex-government officials and some government officials who were involved in the original policy discussions.
What is the biggest unintended consequence of FATCA?
One of the most significant unintended consequences is that the US federal government, meaning the IRS, the Treasury Department, and Congress, never initially even contemplated USCs and LPRs living overseas. An unintended consequence is one that was never contemplated by Congress or the President when the laws were passed, nor intended by the Treasury Department as the IGAs were negotiated. The heavy compliance burden now felt by Americans and green-card holders abroad was a consequence of this kind, not part of the original plan.
Why has it been hard for the IRS to collect taxes from Americans living abroad?
For many years, the US federal government has known it can be nearly impossible to collect a tax liability against US citizens who live and hold their assets outside the United States. The Treasury Department made this point back in 1998, noting that because the United States asserts taxing jurisdiction over people with little or no connection to the country other than citizenship or status as a lawful permanent resident, overseas US taxpayers are in many cases difficult to trace or contact. Treasury added that even when valid tax assessments can be made against overseas taxpayers, the IRS has limited enforcement recourse if the taxpayer’s assets are physically located outside the United States. This appears on pages 13 to 15 of that 1998 Treasury report.
Did the early offshore disclosure programs account for people living overseas?
The original offshore voluntary disclosure initiative in 2009 never even contemplated any particular treatment for USCs or LPRs residing overseas. At that time, the US citizen or green-card holder living abroad was not on the IRS radar. The programs shifted over time:
- In 2011, a new category imposed a 5% penalty for persons residing overseas who had only US$10,000 of US-source income.
- As the IRS realized that millions of USCs and LPRs live somewhere other than the US, the 2014 OVDP was modified again to provide a 0% penalty in certain circumstances for these individuals.
FATCA itself was originally passed in 2010, and at that point USCs and LPRs living overseas were not the focus and barely a thought.
Are Americans living overseas now a focus of the government?
Yes. Even the Senate has started to focus on US citizens living overseas. The Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations focused extensively on Swiss accounts opened by US citizens living outside the United States. Its findings appear in the report titled Offshore Tax Evasion: The Effort to Collect Unpaid Taxes on Billions in Hidden Offshore Accounts, dated February 26, 2014.
Read the full analysis here.
Read the full analysis here.
What Tax Forms Do US Citizens and Green Card Holders Living Abroad Need?
Living outside the United States does not eliminate your US tax obligations. US citizens and green card holders abroad must file a US tax return every year and may also need to file additional reports on foreign assets and accounts. Here is an overview of the key forms, what they cover, and how they interact.
Table of contents:
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE)
Foreign Tax Credits (FTC)
Information Reporting and FBAR
Tax Preparation Software
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE)
Is my foreign income automatically exempt from US reporting?
No. A common misconception is that foreign income is exempt because it can be excluded. Foreign earned income is not exempt. You must report it on a US tax return, and you must be a qualifying individual to elect the exclusion.
What types of income qualify for the exclusion on Form 2555?
The exclusion is available only for “earned” income. It cannot be used for passive investment income such as dividends, interest, or capital gains.
Foreign Tax Credits (FTC)
How does a Foreign Tax Credit work?
A Foreign Tax Credit provides a dollar-for-dollar reduction, subject to limitations, of your US federal tax burden for income taxes you paid to another country on income sourced there. It is claimed on Form 1116.
Can I claim both the FEIE and the Foreign Tax Credit?
No. Once you choose to exclude foreign earned income or housing costs, you cannot take a foreign tax credit on that same income. If you do take the credit, your previous choice to exclude that income may be treated as revoked.
Are there different forms for lawful permanent residents (LPRs)?
US citizens and LPRs generally use Form 1040. However, LPRs residing in a country with a US income tax treaty may be eligible to file Form 1040NR as a non-resident.
What is Form 8938?
Form 8938 (Statement of Specified Foreign Financial Assets) is used to report specified foreign financial assets. It often overlaps with FBAR reporting and must be attached to your annual income tax return when filed with the IRS.
Who must file an FBAR (Form 114)?
US citizens and LPRs with a financial interest in or signature authority over foreign accounts must file a Foreign Bank Account Report (FBAR). The definitions of “ownership interest” and “signature authority” are interpreted very broadly under the regulations.
Where is the FBAR filed?
Unlike other tax forms, the FBAR is not filed with the IRS. You must file it electronically with FinCEN (the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network) through the BSA E-Filing System on Form 114.
What are the penalties for FBAR non-compliance?
The statutory penalty for failing to file, or filing late, is $10,000 per failure. If the failure to file was intentional, the penalty can increase to 50% of the account balances.
There are important unintended tax consequences that can befall individuals who have a green card depending upon their factual circumstances: see, Oops…Did I “Expatriate” and Never Know It: Lawful Permanent Residents Beware! International Tax Journal, CCH Wolters Kluwer, Jan.-Feb. 2014, Vol. 40 Issue 1, p9).
Tax Preparation Software
Can I use standard tax software for these international forms?
Often, no. Most tax preparation software does not support Form 8938 or other forms related to non-US assets. These forms frequently require manual completion using an Adobe Acrobat version of the form.
Read the full analysis here.
Why Is My Foreign Bank Asking Me for a US Tax ID Number?
If you are a US citizen or green card holder living abroad, your local bank may have asked you to provide a US taxpayer identification number before opening an account. This is a consequence of FATCA, a US law that requires foreign banks to identify their American clients. Here is what is happening.
Table of contents:
What is FATCA and why does it affect my foreign bank?
Why does my foreign bank need my US tax ID number?
What if I have never had a Social Security Number?
What is FATCA and why does it affect my foreign bank?
FATCA, the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, took effect in 2014. It requires foreign financial institutions worldwide to identify their US account holders. This obligation extends to financial institutions worldwide.
A “US account” includes an account held by a US citizen who has lived all or almost all of their life outside the United States. The US Treasury has summarized FATCA’s purpose as obtaining information on accounts held by US taxpayers in other countries, as well as accounts held by certain foreign entities with substantial US owners, needed to detect and deter offshore tax evasion.
To enforce this, US financial institutions are required to withhold a portion of certain payments made to foreign financial institutions that do not agree to identify and report information on US account holders. This withholding regime acts as a backstop to FATCA’s main focus. The details and complexity of FATCA are significant, involving hundreds of pages of regulations.
Why does my foreign bank need my US tax ID number?
When you open a new account, your foreign bank must determine whether you are a US person. If you are a US citizen or lawful permanent resident (green card holder), it must collect your US taxpayer identification number (TIN). Under US tax law, a US citizen has no choice but to obtain a Social Security Number (SSN) as their TIN. Your bank will ask you to provide it, typically through IRS Form W-9 or a substitute form provided by the bank.
What if I have never had a Social Security Number?
Here is the catch-22. A US citizen who has spent virtually all of their life outside the United States will typically have no SSN. This includes people who were born in the US but raised abroad, and those who acquired citizenship through a US citizen parent, known as derivative citizenship. The bank asks for a TIN, but you do not have one to give.
The same problem arises for lawful permanent residents (green card holders) who have lived outside the United States for most of their lives. An LPR who never worked or filed taxes in the US may have no SSN or ITIN on record, yet their foreign bank now demands one under FATCA. The process of obtaining an SSN or ITIN as someone living outside the United States is particularly complex and will be addressed in a separate post.
This post provides general information only and is not legal advice. Consult an experienced attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Read the full analysis here.
Can a US Citizen Sign a W-8 Form Instead of a W-9?
When your foreign bank asks you to complete a W-9 form as a US person, you may wonder whether you can sign a W-8 form instead to avoid FATCA reporting. The short answer is no. For US citizens, signing a W-8 is not a legal alternative. Here is why.
Table of contents:
What forms do foreign banks collect from US persons?
Can a US citizen sign a W-8 form?
What about derivative citizenship?
What is the difference between physical residency and tax residency?
What are the legal consequences of signing the wrong form?
Foreign financial institutions worldwide are required under FATCA to collect an IRS Form W-9, or a substitute W-9 form, from their US account holders. These forms may be provided in the local language of the country where the bank operates. US citizens are US persons, and most LPRs are also US persons under this definition. The goal is to identify “US persons” under US federal tax law.
Can a US citizen sign a W-8 form?
No. Under US tax law (26 USC § 6109), the only taxpayer identification number an individual US citizen may use is their Social Security Number. A US citizen, even one who has never lived a day in the United States, cannot legally sign an IRS Form W-8 certifying they are not a US person. Doing so would be signing a false document.
What about derivative citizenship?
Some people are US citizens without realizing it, through a process called derivative citizenship. A person born outside the United States to a parent who was a US citizen may have automatically acquired US citizenship at birth. The US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) provides a Nationality Chart 1 for children born outside the United States to help determine whether citizenship was acquired at birth through a US citizen parent. If you have derivative US citizenship, you are a US person and you cannot sign a W-8.
What is the difference between physical residency and tax residency?
There are two different concepts of residency. Physical residence refers to where a person actually lives. Tax residence, for US federal tax purposes, is determined by citizenship or LPR status, not by where you live. A US citizen who has not lived in the United States for many years is nevertheless treated as a US income tax resident, meaning a “US person,” for FATCA and tax purposes.
What are the legal consequences of signing the wrong form?
Any US individual income tax resident who intentionally signs a false IRS Form W-8 is filing a false document, which falls under the purview of IRC Section 7206(1), the federal perjury statute.
This post provides general information only and is not legal advice. Consult an experienced attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Read the full analysis here.
Why You Need to Plan Before Renouncing US Citizenship
Giving up U.S. citizenship or a green card can trigger an immediate income tax bill, and the IRS may be able to collect it indefinitely, no matter where you live. The rules can also reach your friends and family. This post explains why tax planning generally comes before the paperwork, who the expatriation rules can affect, what the U.S. Department of State forms are, and how hard the tax may be to collect once you live abroad. Consulting an experienced attorney before taking any of these steps is essential.
Table of contents:
Read the full analysis here.
Why does tax planning usually come before giving up U.S. citizenship or a green card?
U.S. international tax law is complex. Without planning, people can create very adverse tax consequences for themselves and for their friends and family, often without understanding the full implications of the law. This is especially true for tax expatriation, which is when a U.S. citizen (USC) renounces citizenship or a long-term lawful permanent resident (LPR), meaning a green card holder, abandons that status. Several features of the law make planning ahead important.
What is the general income tax rule when someone expatriates?
The general rule is that an immediate income tax is payable under the “mark to market” taxation rules on unrealized gains. Mark to market means that unrealized gains, the increase in value of assets that have not actually been sold, are treated as if the assets were sold and are taxed right away. This can produce an income tax bill at the time of expatriation, even though nothing has actually been sold.
Can the IRS collect the expatriation tax from someone living outside the United States?
Yes. Once a tax is recognized under U.S. tax law, the only way to discharge the liability with the U.S. federal government is to pay the tax owing. The IRS generally can collect an income tax owing against a taxpayer who lives outside the U.S. indefinitely. The normal 10 year collection statute does not apply while the individual is outside the United States for a continuous period of at least six months, under IRC Section 6503(c). In effect, the IRS can “forever” pursue collection of the expatriation tax against U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents living outside the U.S.
Can someone become a covered expatriate even with no assets?
Yes. It is easy to fall into the general rule of expatriation, even for a taxpayer who would not otherwise be subject to income taxation. A person who falls into these rules is called a “covered expatriate.” Because covered expatriate status can attach even to someone with no assets, it is sometimes described as a “Forever Taint.”
Can your friends and family be taxed because of your expatriation?
Yes. The friends and family of a covered expatriate, meaning a former U.S. citizen or long-term lawful permanent resident who fell into these rules, can be subject to U.S. taxation during their lifetimes, even if they also live outside the United States. This consequence comes from Section 2801, sometimes called the “Hidden Tax” of expatriation and another part of its “Forever Taint.”
Renouncing U.S. citizenship involves going to the U.S. Department of State and taking the oath of renunciation. Two forms are completed and filed at that time:
- Form DS-4080, Oath of Renunciation of the Nationality of the United States.
- Form DS-4081, Statement of Understanding Concerning the Consequences and Ramifications of Relinquishment or Renunciation of U.S. Citizenship.
The reason planning generally comes first is that these are the steps that formally complete the renunciation, after the tax consequences are already in motion.
If you live abroad with no U.S. assets, can the IRS still collect?
It may be difficult. If the individual lives outside the U.S., does not travel to and from the U.S., and has no assets in the U.S., it may be practically very difficult for the IRS to collect on the tax judgment owing. Even so, there are legal means and steps the IRS can take in an attempt to collect U.S. taxes on assets held overseas.
Why is planning important before renouncing citizenship or abandoning a green card?
Ideally, a former U.S. citizen or long-term lawful permanent resident will want to avoid these potential tax and collection issues by engaging in thoughtful and strategic planning before renouncing U.S. citizenship or abandoning lawful permanent residency. Because expatriation can trigger an immediate tax, long-term collection exposure, and tax consequences for family members, the planning generally comes before the renunciation paperwork. Consulting an experienced attorney before taking any of these steps is essential.
Read the full analysis here.
What Happens If You Become a Covered Expatriate?
Not everyone who renounces US citizenship faces the same tax consequences. People who qualify as “covered expatriates” face significant additional obligations. Here is what that means and how even modest individuals can end up in this category.
Table of contents:
The trap for the unwary: Section 877(a)(2)(C)
What are the three tests for covered expatriate status?
What happens at the embassy or consulate?
The trap for the unwary: Section 877(a)(2)(C)
One of the greatest risks for anyone who wants to give up US citizenship is Section 877(a)(2)(C). Even the most economically modest individual, with little assets or income, can fall into this trap. No one at the US Department of State will provide tax advice or interpret Section 877(a)(2)(C) for you. The renunciation appointment itself is straightforward. The tax consequences are not.
What are the three tests for covered expatriate status?
Under Section 877(a)(2), you are a covered expatriate if any one of the following is true:
(A) Your average annual net income tax liability is greater than $124,000;
(B) Your net worth is $2,000,000 or more as of your expatriation date; or
(C) You fail to certify under penalty of perjury that you have met all US tax requirements for the 5 preceding taxable years, or fail to submit the required evidence of compliance.
Any individual who meets any one of these tests will be a covered expatriate and subject to the taxation and reporting requirements under Sections 877, 877A, and 2801.
What happens at the embassy or consulate?
When you take the renunciation oath at a US embassy or consulate, the Foreign Affairs Manual provides only standard overview language about “special tax consequences.” The consular officer will not explain the specific rules of Section 877(a)(2)(C) or tell you whether you will be a covered expatriate. This is worth understanding well before going to take the oath.
This post provides general information only and is not legal advice. Consult an experienced attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Read the full analysis here.
What Documents Should You Request When Renouncing US Citizenship?
When you attend your renunciation appointment, it is important to know exactly what paperwork you will be handling and what documentation you should take home with you. Here is a guide to help you navigate the process.
Table of contents:
What forms will you sign?
What documents should you request?
Why is the date on your receipt so important?
What happens with the Certificate of Loss of Nationality (CLN)?
Does every consulate follow the same rules?
During your appointment, you will typically sign two primary documents: Form DS-4080, which is your formal Oath of Renunciation, and Form DS-4081, a statement confirming that you understand the serious consequences of giving up your citizenship. If you do not speak English, you will also need to sign Form DS-4082, which is a witnesses’ attestation.
What documents should you request?
The government does not always automatically provide copies of the forms you sign, so you need to be proactive.
The Payment Receipt: You are entitled to a receipt for the $450 fee you pay to renounce. This is a “mere receipt,” but it is arguably the most important piece of paper you will receive that day.
An Acknowledgment Letter: Some embassies or consulates provide a letter that officially acknowledges you have taken the oath. If available, this letter will state that the Department of State will submit your Certificate of Loss of Nationality (CLN) for approval and that the consulate is retaining your U.S. passport.
Why is the date on your receipt so important?
You must keep your payment receipt in a safe place because it records the exact date of your renunciation meeting. This date is critical for your U.S. tax obligations. Under specific tax laws (Section 7701(a)(50)), this date marks a major transition and is used for timing purposes regarding your final tax responsibilities.
What happens with the Certificate of Loss of Nationality (CLN)?
You will not receive your CLN at the appointment. After you take your oath, the Department of State reviews your case. If they approve the renunciation, they will then issue the CLN. Until then, the acknowledgment letter (if your consulate provides one) serves as proof that the process is underway.
Does every consulate follow the same rules?
No, the experience can vary depending on where your appointment is held. Some offices routinely provide acknowledgment letters or copies of signed forms, while others do not. Because of this inconsistency, you should always double-check what you are given before leaving your appointment to ensure you have the proof you need for your records.
This post provides general information only and is not legal advice. Consult an experienced attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
Read the full analysis here.
