Why vested Social Security Retirement Benefits are not lost when a USC or LPR sheds their citizenship or immigration status. The Answer to: What happens to social security benefits to former USCs and LPRS including a “covered expatriate”?

Posted on Updated on

The law of the Social Security Act is a bit obscure for persons who are not (i..e, no longer are) U.S. citizens.   It is “obscure” because the law is silent as to former U.S. citizens.  For basic background, see, Social Security Retirement Benefits – for former USCs and LPRs (Intersection of U.S. Tax and Social Security Law)

While USCs have broad, largely unfettered rights to social security (including when they reside exclusively outside the United States), former USCs and LPRs fall into a different category, specifically including the tax treatment of those benefits.

Also, the U.S. Congress has imposed limitations, first under the so-called Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 and later by the Social Security Protection Act of 2004.Social Security Emblym - SSA

For the “Accidental American” who has spent virtually all of their lives outside the U.S. (and has never been employed by a U.S. employer), this discussion will largely be irrelevant to you as you will probably have no rights to Social Security Retirement Benefits.

However, for the former USC or LPR who falls into any of the following categories, and worked full-time for the requisite 40 quarters, they should have Social Security Retirement Benefits that are due and payable when they meet the age requirements:

  1. self-employed (and paid and filed self-employment tax returns – paying social security); or
  2. employed within the United States (even by a foreign employer); or
  3. employed outside the United States by a U.S. employer.

For a detailed discussion of how and when these federal employment taxes apply (including at what rates), please see  “Comparative Overview of U.S. and Mexican Federal Employment Taxes,” CCH International Tax Journal, November–December 2009.   Current Social Security Tax Rates, and the taxable base – contribution base (which adjusts annually) can be reviewed on the Social Security Website.

The 1996 and 2004 statutory amendments reflected above, do not modify the rights of former USCs or LPRs.  They do affect the rights of individuals who were not USCs or LPRs; namely who did not have legal immigration status while working and living in the U.S.

For a detailed discussion of this part of the law, please see the Congressional Research Report of 2010 titled Social Security Benefits for Noncitizens.

The final conclusion about whether the Social Security Act restricts social security retirement benefits to “covered expatriates”, can NOT be expressly found in the statute or the regulations themselves.  There is no affirmative answer in Title 42 or the regulations thereunder, regarding “covered expatriates.”  It is silent on the issue and not expressly addressed.

Most importantly, throughout the Social Security Act and regulations thereunder, because of the “silence” of the statute, there are no restrictions expressly imposed on “covered expatriates” or any other former USCs or LPRs.  This category of persons, “covered expatriates” is not somehow identified or segregated in the law for disparate treatment.  The law provides generally that Social Security Retirement Benefits are available to non-citizens and those who no longer have LPR status; provided they meet the previous work and eligibility requirements.  Shedding USC or LPR does not strip these individuals of these benefits.

While it is always hard (impossible) to “prove a negative”; our office has also received telephonic confirmation from technical support personnel of the Social Security Administration, that the above conclusion is a correct interpretation of the law.

Stay tuned to another post about how the U.S. imposes income and withholding taxes on Social Security benefits to “covered expatriates”; which is indeed different than for current USCs (and some LPRs) residing overseas.

 

 

请点击这里查看本帖子的中文版本。 Please click here to view the above in Chinese.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s